This chapter provides a detailed description of how to write documentation using one of the supported formats. It is aimed at both PEAR developers that are already maintaining packages in PEAR and at people who are planning to contribute a new package.
DocBook is an XML dialect that is used by a wide range of projects to maintain their documentation. Examples for DocBook usage in OpenSource projects are the documentations of KDE and PHP. PEAR has opted for using DocBook, because we believe that it provides a solid foundation for the technical documentation for PEAR packages.
The trade-off for using DocBook is that it is relatively hard to use. Testing documentation requires a number of tools to be installed and one needs to learn a (not very complicated) XML dialect. Once one is familiar with how DocBook works, they will enjoy writing documentation with it though.
The book [DocBook: The Definitive Guide], written by Norman Walsh and Leonard Muellner and published by O'Reilly & Associates, Inc., is available online and it makes up a great resource for people interested in learning DocBook.
Definitely check out the book's "DocBook Element Reference" section. This portion provides detailed information about each element, including which elements can (and must) be used as parents and children.
Even if DocBook XML can (like any other XML file) be written using a normal text editor, it is optimal for users to install some software on their machine in order to test the validity of the documenting efforts. A list of the required software and installation instructions can be found in the PHP Documentation HOWTO. Apart from providing information about the software, this HOWTO also provides a ton of other useful information that goes far beyond this chapter. One is encouraged to read it completely. (Chapter II can be skipped, because it only contains information that is very PHP specific.)
Installation on OS X: The PHP Documentation HOWTO advises users of Mac OS X to use packages provided by Fink. Alternatively packages from the MacPorts project can be used. After installing MacPorts, the toolchain can be installed using the following command:
Unfortunately, installing that software can be difficult under some circumstances. If you are unable to get it working, don't use that as an excuse for not writing documentation. There are two test servers that automatically download peardoc from CVS and build the manual. Any parsing errors your changes cause will show up in the logs the next time the build happens:
|Build from Brett Bieber (log) (updated every two hours)|
|Build from TAKAGI Masahiro (log) (updated daily at 06:00 JST = 21:00 UTC)|
The manual on the PEAR website is built only once per week. Any XML validation errors will cause the build to fail. If the main build fails, the old version remains in place, meaning the manual will be out of date. Therefore, always check the test build logs to ensure your changes are valid. More importantly, do not commit updates shortly before the main build happens (Sundays ~12:00 UTC).
Once the necessary software is in place, one has to get the latest version of the XML sources from PEAR's CVS repository:
$ cvs -d :pserver:<user>@cvs.php.net:/repository login [password] $ cvs -d :pserver:<user>@cvs.php.net:/repository co peardoc
If you do not own an account for cvs.php.net, please choose cvsread as the username. When asked for the password, type phpfi.
After that the directory ./peardoc will contain a local copy ("sandbox") of the latest sources. If you are not yet familiar with CVS, then the online book "Open Source Development with CVS" will provide you with all the necessary information.
This chapter will not describe all the details about the directory structure, because one can find out the essentials about it by browsing the previously created directory peardoc. As a starting point for package documenters peardoc/en/package/ fits well. If one has further questions concerning the directory structure, they can ask on the documentation mailinglist.
Instead of a long and boring description for writing documentation using DocBook, we would like to point you to a bunch of "reference documents", from which you should be able to learn quickly:
The CVS tree has a complete set of DocBook XML templates. These files provide the standard of how PEAR documentation should look.
The simplest way to utilize them is to copy them to your working directory, rename them accordingly, edit the contents to match the reality of your program and then upload them to your package's directory in the repository.
The documentation for HTTP_Request, which is a relatively small package, only consists of a bunch of end-user documentation, which describes all of the basic features of the package. Each feature description includes at least one example. For small packages with only a handful of methods this documentation type is absolutely enough.
XML_Beautifier is a package that is also relatively compact, but which supports different configuration options. These options are described in the documentation Additionally the documentation gives usage examples and (unlike HTTP_Request) also includes API documentation for its methods.
DB is a large PEAR package and has excellent documentation, including usage examples. The DB docs carefully adhere to the formatting specified in peardoc/authoring. The link above goes to the DocBook source code in the CVS repository. It might be helpful to examine the HTML generated therefrom.
In addition to the examples above, you will find much more documentation examples by browsing the peardoc directory, which contains your local version of the CVS tree. Especially the directory peardoc/en/packages/ should be of interest for you. You can also browse the CVS module using the web interface, including the raw XML for the file you are presently reading.
Creating dozens of files, one for each function in each class of your package is rather boring. Luckily, we have the PhpDocumentor in PEAR which has a renderer to generate templates for your classes and methods.
Create a test directory and cd into it. Then, run the following command: phpdoc -p on -f /path/to/my/package/source/File.php -t . -o "XML:DocBook/peardoc2:default" -dc myPackageCategory After creating the files, check if they are all ok and edit them - add examples, additional documentation and remove unnecessary sections.
Note: phpdoc generates documentation templates. The generated docs are by no means complete, you need to edit them afterwards!
Generating human-readable versions of the DocBook sources requires the existence of the above-mentioned software. The PEAR documentation system uses Unix style makefiles:
peardoc$ autoconf peardoc$ ./configure --with-lang=en peardoc$ make html
If you want to build a language other than English, change en, above, to the appropriate language code.
It may be that the DSSSL stylesheets are not found, resulting in the message
checking for docbook.dsl... defaulting - WARNING!!! DSSSL NOT FOUND - WON'T WORK THIS WAY
In this case make sure you've installed the DSSSL packages. On a Mac using Fink, you might have to specify the location yourself: ./configure --with-dsssl=/sw/share/sgml/dsssl/docbook-dsssl-nwalsh
On Windows, the easiest way to get the DSSSL sheets is to check out the phpdoc module on cvs.php.net - they can be found in the dsssl/ subdirectory.
This will generate a "raw" HTML version of the whole manual. The result will be placed in the subdirectory html/.
The command make test does not generate any human-readable result, but it can be used to make sure that the XML is syntactically correct and that the build runs fine. And it is much faster than make html.
Numerous developers have reported problems when using the make html command, namely that the output was not written to a file but instead dumped on the console. If you encounter this problem and have checked out the DocBook sources into e.g. /home/you/cvs/peardoc, checkout the phpdoc module (using the procedure described above) into /home/you/cvs/phpdoc, and run make html again.
In addition to testing the well-formedness of the DocBook sources, xmllint can also check the semantical correctness with the help of RELAX NG schemas. The schema files for DocBook are available as a ZIP package from docbook.org. After unzipping the package into the directory relaxng/ inside the peardoc source folder, one can run xmllint from the root folder of the PEAR documentation as follows:
xmllint --valid --noout --relaxng relaxng/ manual.xml
The build process (not the test builds, which are reasonably quick) actually takes a very long time which makes debugging and testing a very hard task. In order to increase build performance, the script make-partial.php in the root directory of the documentation module may be used. This is an interactive command line script that will enable to you to selectively include the different parts of the manual. In the following example a version of the manual is generated which only contains a certain part of the Developer's Guide and the documentation for the HTTP packages. Using these partial builds reduces the build time dramatically.
peardoc$ ./make-partial.php Include about-pear? [NO] Include guide-newmaint? [NO] Include guide-developers? [NO] y Include guide.developers.intro? [NO] Include guide.developers.meaning? [NO] Include guide.developers.contributing? [NO] Include guide.developers.packagedef? [NO] Include guide.developers.release? [NO] Include guide.developers.supporting? [NO] Include guide.developers.recommendations? [NO] Include guide.developers.documentation? [NO] y Include core? [NO] Include packages? [NO] y Include package.authentication? [NO] Include package.benchmarking? [NO] Include package.caching? [NO] Include package.configuration? [NO] Include package.console? [NO] Include package.database? [NO] Include package.datetime? [NO] Include package.encryption? [NO] Include package.fileformats? [NO] Include package.filesystem? [NO] Include package.gtk? [NO] Include package.html? [NO] Include package.http? [NO] y Include package.images? [NO] Include package.internationalization? [NO] Include package.logging? [NO] Include package.mail? [NO] Include package.math? [NO] Include package.networking? [NO] Include package.numbers? [NO] Include package.payment? [NO] Include package.pear? [NO] Include package.php? [NO] Include package.science? [NO] Include package.streams? [NO] Include package.structures? [NO] Include package.system? [NO] Include package.text? [NO] Include package.tools? [NO] Include package.xml? [NO] Include package.webservices? [NO] CONFIG_FILES=manual.xml CONFIG_HEADERS= ./config.status creating manual.xml /usr/bin/jade -wno-idref -d html.dsl -V use-output-dir -t sgml ./phpdocxml.dcl manual.xml
In make-partial.php, takes a long time to complete all questions. make partial with the correct parameters is much faster, e.g. make partial INCLUDE="packages package.database". The full list of IDs can be obtained by inspecting the output of make.
Translating documentation is another important task. Existing translations need to be brought up to date because the English versions have been changed. Help on how to perform the translation process is in the Revision Tracking section of the manual.
We are well aware that we cannot cover all questions about writing DocBook documentation in this chapter. If you have more questions or problems, do not hesitate to get in touch with the documentation team at firstname.lastname@example.org. To join the pear-doc list send an email to email@example.com.
Also consider reading the Documentation FAQ.